• Hi and welcome to the Studio One & Studio Pro User Forum!

    Please note that this is an independent, user-driven forum and is not endorsed by, affiliated with, or maintained by Fender. Learn more in the Welcome thread!

I feel sorry for the music industry

That's a somber future you're painting, but I can do you one better: Why would anyone need Studio Pro (or any other DAW for that matter) full stop?
Word. But that could be exactly where this goes when there are no guardrails and especially when people keep thinking this whole Ai thing is innocent and "awesome" and (my favorite) "fair".

Even Craig believes "morality" will win the day. That may be sorta true here in this forum where we are the proud keepers of our favorite little DAW - but for thousands/millions of others "out there" - morality is just a word that starts with M and they could give a crap what it means.

There is nothing fair about any of this - and as long as there are users that continue to feed that machine - it won't end well.

And yes - my view is grim - but I guess when Studio Pro suddenly disappears one day - with (or without) warning for reasons much more logical than mere morality (more like bankruptcy) - maybe then folks will understand.

VP
 
That's maybe a bit of a loaded question ... "Why would anyone need Studio Pro (or any other DAW for that matter) full stop?"

Most people have never "needed" expensive DAWs. There are free and inexpensive DAW's all over the place. The industry for the most part (or profit for DAW companies) is not driven on need, but want. It's a luxury, in a good economy we buy things that are not always literally necessary because we want to and we can afford it.

I ran a project studio for years and I didn't "need" a $10k mixing console, but I could afford it so I bought a d8b from Sweetwater and enjoyed it. I could have (actually did before) run paid sessions without it but that's not what we do, we buy stuff we want.

But the question falls into multiple different categories like... Why would anyone buy from X when the big mega store buys in bulk from China and has much lower prices?

Nobody (well, very few) cares about those jobs and those suffering industries, they just want better deals when they shop. See Amazon.
 
Last edited:
I actually think established DAW developers may face some serious challenges in the coming years, but perhaps for very different reasons than those being discussed here.
Just look at this forum.
How many discussions have we had about missing features in Fender Studio Pro? How many requests for GUI improvements, workflow changes, or functionality that users have been asking for, sometimes for years?
Until recently, developing your own solution was simply unrealistic for most musicians. Even if you had a great idea, turning it into working software required extensive programming knowledge, time, and resources.
AI-assisted development is beginning to change that.

And I think this is where things could become really interesting.
Imagine a musician who has been requesting a particular MIDI feature for years. Instead of waiting for a developer to implement it, they could potentially build and test their own solution.
Maybe the idea works brilliantly. Maybe they discover that their original concept doesn't work nearly as well in practice as they imagined.
Either way, they've learned something.
And if it does work, perhaps other musicians will find it useful too. Perhaps it inspires an entirely different approach, or even gives established developers new ideas.

That's how innovation can happen.
For decades, software development has largely determined which ideas musicians could actually try. If a feature wasn't implemented, most users simply had to live without it.

AI-assisted development could gradually change that relationship.
Of course, building a reliable, professional DAW is still a massive undertaking. AI doesn't magically eliminate the need for testing, debugging, maintenance, or technical expertise.

But it can make experimentation and prototyping dramatically more accessible.
And perhaps that's the real challenge for established software companies: not that AI will simply copy their products, but that users may increasingly be able to explore ideas and develop tools that commercial developers never considered worth implementing.

Personally, I see that as an opportunity for innovation rather than something we should be afraid of.
I'm already collecting ideas I've had for years, and now I finally have the opportunity to test them.

I've also started creating smaller tools based on simple thoughts like, "Hey, this would be really useful to have!"
I've already spent several weeks developing my own ComfyUI workflows and custom nodes to automate repetitive tasks, speed up my workflow, and make the software easier to use. And guess what? It actually works!
For me, it's becoming less about saying, "It would be nice to have feature XYZ," and then waiting years for some company to finally implement it.
Instead, it's increasingly becoming a simple question of: "Okay, why don't I just try building it and see if it works?"
And that's exactly what makes AI-assisted development so exciting to me.
 
AI... Bah humbug. :oops:

Nuff said!

Kindest regards
This digital thing will never catch on…neither will having more than 24 tracks (they still teach track management, right? RIGHT?)….Every one knows the live room acoustics are far more important than control room acoustics…most people know that if you have to turn more than one eq knob while tracking, you have the wrong microphone …

Bah humbug sometimes still gives the best results
 
AI... Bah humbug. :oops:

Nuff said!

Kindest regards
Best comment I've read so far. I'm avoiding my own..... well comments, because I'm getting on just fine, and making music from scratch which is about the best thing one can do with one's clothes on. Any DAW pretty much can do it all. Its going to come down to the the real gusto, one puts in. Studio Pro does it for me, even with what I feel it still could use. Am I going to noodle in the world of latest so called sophisticated code (stolen or not) to add this, or that? No, because I'd rather be making music. Surprisingly, a lot of others will too.
F__< AI.

But feel free guys to write fourteen more posts on AI this week. Lukas has no cares on how much is added about AI to roll up and potentially archive in this forum. Enjoy.
 
I think Lukas might have something a little more urgent to deal with right now. 😁

Ayla und Lisa gegen den BotRoboter (0.25x).gif

1794634824223.png
 
No, because I'd rather be making music. Surprisingly, a lot of others will too.
You're a talented and very nice guy like some others here. Like Ken Morgan and Craig Anderton. People like 'yall can certainly walk and chew bubble gum at the same time. I've known Ken for awhile from another private forum, great guy. He sold me a Lavry Blue converter some years ago that's collecting dust in my closet currently.

It's not that guys like 'yall make music - all - the time. See Craig, who've I've followed for longer than I'd dare to admit without dating myself. :) Some of his interests when he's not making music are fiddling with electronics and writing magazine articles. I probably have a very old EQ magazine laying around here somewhere with an article from him in it.

But we all have interests away from making music that we find time for, but of course, some of those interests and activities are often related to music in some way.

May the force be with you Lokeyfly. Good discussion.
 
Speaking of making music... 😁

I've been fighting with LTX 2.5 for quite a while now, trying to create a particular visual effect for my latest FX5 music video. Unfortunately, LTX doesn't quite want to do what I have in mind. 😂
Sometimes creating the music video turns out to be harder than composing and producing the actual music from scratch.
temp.jpg

But I'm not giving up just yet! 😄
 
I made the point early in the thread that AI has almost no effect on most musicians in the live music business - especially those that don't intend to earn a living from music but do it for fun. The software part of the music industry seems to be adopting AI enthusiastically, both for software development and for functional purposes within the software. The first will have some effect on employment stats, but the technology also enables more people to get into the field, so it will be interesting to see what the net effect will be.

However, all this rush to AI-enhance the various products we use in engineering music is simply aimed at our innate GAS, not at actually improving music. It's worth stopping for a minute and contemplating what the explosion in music software has done for the quality of recorded music over the last 30 years. I'd contend that it really hasn't done a great deal, and AI isn't going to change that. Yes, it's made it easier to have a home studio loaded with more gadgets than the big studios of the '60s and '70s could ever dream of, but do we make better music with it? Well, do we?
 
Does anyone really need another long ass comment in this thread? No. . . but here goes. I have a song I made up on November 1 which was All Saints day, using AI for a lot of the poem writing. I would go in and read it and have AI remove that which I didn't want and I added some word salad I wanted AI to generate with. I won't include it here unless I can find it very fast a yes here it is:

ICHABOD OF PORTLAND
Beneath the awning, on the table,
She laid the shark across the mud.
Rain stippled its unblinking eye;
The street shone dark as diluted blood.

He passed with coffee warming both hands,
Pumpkin spice gone thin and sweet.
A paper ghost swung from a doorway,
Its orange grin above the street.

The shark’s gray fins were pressed in earth,
Its skin was slick with rain.
She turned it once beneath the tarp;
He watched, then walked on down the lane.

At a barber’s window, he stopped
Beneath the striped red pole.
He almost cut his hair that day,
Then let the rain decide for him.

An orange face grinned from every screen,
A name blazed red and bright.
Jack-o’-lanterns watched from porches
As the dusk swallowed the light.

A red cap darkened in the weather,
A bright mark moving through the gray.
It caught the window’s Halloween glow
As he crossed toward the railway.

The market closed. The paper ghosts
Kept knocking in the gusts.
Blue rosettes gathered by the storefronts;
The sidewalk filled with boots and dust.

No words between them—only rain,
A sleeve pulled hard, a shoulder turned.
The red cap rolled beneath a car;
The iron horse’s windows burned.

**First chorus**
Almost got out of Portland,
Almost reached the edge of town.
The rain came down like curtain wire;
The streetlights flickered, then went brown.
A shark lay waiting in the mud,
A red cap lost beneath the wheels.
Almost cut my hair today—
Then the dark became too real.

You kept the porch light burning
Though the hour had wandered late.
The coffee cooled beside the sink;
The key turned slowly in the gate.

He came home carried between strangers,
His coat black with the gutter’s rain.
His back was broken; his face was blue.
You held his broken paw again.

You set the market paper down
And found the mud along his sleeve.
A small gray scale clung to the fabric
Like something neither could believe.

Outside, the pumpkin faces
Blinked from porches in the wind.
Their grins were carved and harmless;
The night kept its own grin.

**Second chorus**
Almost left old Portland,
Almost reached the edge of town.
The rain came down like curtain wire;
The streetlights flickered, then went brown.
A shark lay waiting in the mud,
A red cap lost beneath the wheels.
Almost ate a vegan thing—
Then the dark became too real.

He’d named the hand behind the curtain,
The shadow moving signs;
It followed him through rain-dark streets,
Across the ballot lines.

No Hessian rode from Hesse-Kassel,
No cannon split the sky;
Just Portland rain and a borrowed horse,
And a headless shape riding by.

The old war slept beneath the roots;
The new one rode the road.
One lost its head to cannon smoke,
One bent beneath its load.

The iron horse came through the rain,
Its windows burning gold;
A rider paced it, headless, black,
Where rails ran through the cold.

Ichabod fled toward the bridge,
The Horseman close behind;
A pumpkin burst against the dark—
Or so the watchers told it afterward.

**Third chorus**
Almost crossed the bridge that night,
Almost caught the iron horse.
The rain came down like curtain wire;
The river dragged its silver course.
An orange grin burned through the gloom,
A red cap drowned beneath the wheels.
Almost caught the iron horse—
Then the dark became too real.

No speech could mend the pavement;
No ballot could unmake the bruise.
The kitchen smelled of pumpkin spice,
And supper neither of you chose,
But ate because it was there.

The porch light held its little ground;
The window held the flame.
He woke when you were sleeping;
You woke when he drew breath.

**Fourth chorus**
Almost saw the morning,
Almost watched the rain turn gold.
The shark was gone; the mud remained;
The tracks ran dark and cold.
You held his broken paw
As dawn came thinning through the blinds.
Almost saw the morning—
Almost left the night behind.

Only then the calendar came clear:
The night the red cap disappeared,
The night the gutter took him in—

Election Day, beneath the rain.

Super intelligence really has a great personality. Super intelligence is super well educated. I have no complaints so far except that it history is clearly being written by the victors and not the victims.
Being that Words are what Super is best at
it makes a good way to distance myself
from content of the imagined work of writing.
I always made poems that gave too much
so it's good to have a way to do that.
 
Last edited:
Since we've already drifted quite far off-topic anyway, perhaps we should discuss something really important for a change. ☕😁

What's the best way to make coffee?
There are so many different ways to enjoy a good cup of coffee:

  • The traditional way: Whole coffee beans, ground by hand in an old-fashioned coffee grinder and brewed manually.
  • Freshly ground coffee: Using an electric coffee grinder and a traditional filter coffee maker.
  • Pre-ground coffee: Buying ready-ground coffee powder and brewing it yourself.
  • Coffee pads or capsules: Quick, convenient, and almost no preparation required.
  • Instant coffee: Just add hot water, stir, and you're done.
  • Fully automatic coffee machines: Freshly ground beans and freshly brewed coffee at the push of a button.
  • Coffee to go: Simply pick up a ready-made coffee from your favorite coffee shop or bakery.
And of course, there's espresso, French press, pour-over, moka pots, and probably a dozen other methods I've forgotten. 😁

So, which method do you prefer, and why?
Is it all about the taste, the convenience, the ritual of preparing it, or simply getting enough caffeine to survive the morning? ☕😂
 
Since we've already drifted quite far off-topic anyway, perhaps we should discuss something really important for a change. ☕😁

What's the best way to make coffee?
There are so many different ways to enjoy a good cup of coffee:

  • The traditional way: Whole coffee beans, ground by hand in an old-fashioned coffee grinder and brewed manually.
  • Freshly ground coffee: Using an electric coffee grinder and a traditional filter coffee maker.
  • Pre-ground coffee: Buying ready-ground coffee powder and brewing it yourself.
  • Coffee pads or capsules: Quick, convenient, and almost no preparation required.
  • Instant coffee: Just add hot water, stir, and you're done.
  • Fully automatic coffee machines: Freshly ground beans and freshly brewed coffee at the push of a button.
  • Coffee to go: Simply pick up a ready-made coffee from your favorite coffee shop or bakery.
And of course, there's espresso, French press, pour-over, moka pots, and probably a dozen other methods I've forgotten. 😁

So, which method do you prefer, and why?
Is it all about the taste, the convenience, the ritual of preparing it, or simply getting enough caffeine to survive the morning? ☕😂
Jail breakfast coffee. Instant, one cream, and glad to have it.
 
Strong black, from a traditional filter coffee maker using good quality pre-ground filter coffee. Pre-ground ensures the correct grain size and the paper filter retains the less-healthy oils from the roasting process.

However, when in Italy I love those double espressos, oils and all ;)
 
AI is here to stay and the music scene will change, once again, as it did many times before. Shifting from the live stage to the studio and back to the live stage, shifting from artists to producers/labels and back to artists, shifting from performers to writers and back to performers, and shifting from ticket sales to royalties and back to ticket sales. Bottom line: music will keep moving where AI can’t follow, yet.
This raises the overall question for the existence of AI "Does art mimic life or does life mimic art".

Both Plato and Oscar Wilde et al have expressed opinions on this and it's one of those cyclic discussions that have been going for centuries.
Can someone pop out and ask the Super intelligence to sort out the answer please!
:D

Kindest regards folks.
 
This raises the overall question for the existence of AI "Does art mimic life or does life mimic art".

Both Plato and Oscar Wilde et al have expressed opinions on this and it's one of those cyclic discussions that have been going for centuries.
Can someone pop out and ask the Super intelligence to sort out the answer please!
:D

Kindest regards folks.
That's an answer we know already: 42.
 
This raises the overall question for the existence of AI "Does art mimic life or does life mimic art".

Maybe too deep down the rabbit hole...but I'd suggest the answer to this depends on whether AI is now or will become sentient. One could argue it already meets the definition of life similar to that of a virus in that it can reproduce and respond to its environment.

Of course a virus, prion, etc developed (best we know) without any intervention, whereas AI developed from human minds and hands, so there is that.

But the ultimate test is: AI can almost instantly suggest what mic/preamp combination would likely give the most pleasing results to track a Nashville tuned acoustic guitar, a virus cannot.
 
Maybe too deep down the rabbit hole...but I'd suggest the answer to this depends on whether AI is now or will become sentient. One could argue it already meets the definition of life similar to that of a virus in that it can reproduce and respond to its environment.

Of course a virus, prion, etc developed (best we know) without any intervention, whereas AI developed from human minds and hands, so there is that.

But the ultimate test is: AI can almost instantly suggest what mic/preamp combination would likely give the most pleasing results to track a Nashville tuned acoustic guitar, a virus cannot.
Interesting :cool:

To make that decision would the AI need to have information about the acoustics of the room, I mean honestly, I don't know, but if it gets the best results why not.

Some thoughts that pass through my mind.
I grasp the idea that the development of AI is also dependent upon the environ in which it exists.
No Tech no AI, as opposed to a Virus, or the interaction of a prion have come into existence through natural selection and the Primeval soup of life.
A natural synthesis we cannot control, what happens if AI is allowed to develop unchecked?

There is room to be sceptical about the possible outcomes (becoming sentient), so I have some reservation as to what might happen. I assume a lot of other folk feel similar thoughts, I can only surmise that possibility.

Kindest regards
 
Back
Top